Omissions and misinformation, a little Thursday rant
This morning on the Today Show, they aired a segment about how identity thieves are using people’s file sharing programs to steal their personal information.
Now, I’m not going to go into whether file sharing is amoral or immoral or whatever the ethics behind it are. But the simple fact is that much of it is very illegal. In fact, the song they used as an example was a Beyonce song.
I just sat there marveling as the news report claimed that, “These file sharing programs can have a dark side.” You think? How about the dark side of illegal file sharing?
I was also quite boggled by a quote from a man whose daughter’s file sharing had led to their tax returns being stolen and sold on the international market. He said something like, “I never thought someone could use these programs to commit a crime.”
Seriously, dude?
I’m floored by the massive viewpoint that was left out of this news story. It’s kind of like if they did a story about people who pick the pockets of car thieves while they’re bent over hot-wiring a car.
Look, I don’t care if you file share or don’t. As an author, I have to hope in the name of my own livelihood that somebody doesn’t find a way to share my book online for free.
But the lazy reporting has GOT to GO!
Similarly, this week’s episode of “The Biggest Loser” (which I love) featured a quiz about health and nutrition. The first question was:
“True or false: Switching from regular soda to diet soda will extend your lifespan?”
The contestants answered “false,” and the woman from Prevention magazine said, “Yes! It’s false! Studies show that both diet and regular sodas can lead to metabolic syndrome!”
So how do you get from, “studies show that diet soda can lead to metabolic syndrome” to “diet sodas will NOT extend your lifespan”?
Yes, studies have shown that diet sodas are not always effective because their sweetness can cause people to crave sweets, in which they then indulge, which causes them to gain weight that may contribute to metabolic syndrome.
But that is CORRELATION, my friends, not CAUSALITY. And the absolute “false” renders this ridiculous. I promise you that there are some people out there who switched from regular soda to diet soda and did not get metabolic syndrome, and (gasp!) extended their lifespans.
They didn’t mention how much diet soda vs. how much regular soda. They didn’t mention the health of the person in question. They didn’t put it in context of studies or specific situations.
They just made an ignorant, unsupportable blanket statement and passed it off as a fact.
Bah!
8 comments February 26th, 2009
Blog RSS Feed


